The global push for a clean energy transition is undeniably transforming the way we power our lives. As we shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources and embrace electric vehicles, we face a critical challenge: securing the necessary raw materials, such as lithium, cobalt, and rare earth elements (REEs), to fuel this transformation. The demand for these materials is set to skyrocket, yet uncertainties loom over the ability to meet this demand without causing harm to the environment and communities affected by their extraction.
Clean energy technologies rely on materials like lithium for batteries, cobalt for battery cathodes, and REEs for magnets in wind turbines and electric motors. With the demand for EVs and renewable energy sources expected to rise exponentially as the world transitions to a more sustainable future, the need for these materials will also surge. The World Bank estimates that the demand for lithium, cobalt, and REEs could increase by 1,000% by 2050. However, whether the supply of these materials can keep pace with the expected demand is up for debate.
Source: IEA
The production of these materials is highly concentrated in specific regions and countries. For instance, the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) is a major producer of cobalt, while China dominates the production and refining of rare earth elements. This concentration creates potential geopolitical risks and uncertainties in the supply chain, as governments and international relations can affect the availability and distribution of these materials.
Developing new mines or expanding existing ones requires significant investment and infrastructure development. There might be delays and challenges in securing the necessary financing, permits, and environmental approvals to bring new supply sources online in time to meet the growing demand.
While there might be enough lithium, cobalt, and REEs in the earth's crust, it is uncertain whether they can be extracted in the required timeframe to meet the increasing demand. Additionally, control over the supply of these materials may not always lie with the producer countries, which can affect their availability to other nations.
In addition to the uncertainty of meeting demand for these materials, current extraction procedures have detrimental impacts on the environment and workers. With exceptional demand increases on the way, it’s vital that the following issues are addressed:
The extraction of cobalt, lithium, and REEs often involves energy-intensive processes that contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. Traditional mining methods and the use of chemicals during refining can have a significant carbon footprint.
Mining operations can result in extensive land clearing, deforestation, and habitat loss for local wildlife. This can lead to a loss of biodiversity and have long-term negative consequences for the environment.
The extraction process, particularly for lithium from brine ponds, requires large amounts of water, which can lead to depletion of local water resources. The use of toxic chemicals during the extraction process may also result in water contamination, posing risks to both human populations and ecosystems.
Source: BBC
Mining operations are energy-intensive, and while renewable energy sources can be used to power these operations, many mines still rely on fossil fuels, contributing to overall greenhouse gas emissions.
Mining activities can have negative consequences for local communities, including health hazards from pollution, displacement, and social disruption. Local populations may oppose mining projects due to concerns about environmental degradation and threats to their health and livelihoods.
In some regions, particularly the DRC, the extraction of materials like cobalt has been linked to unethical labour practices, including child labour and poor working conditions.
Thankfully, there are ways to ensure a sustainable and responsible supply of the materials needed for a clean energy transition without compromising the well-being of our planet and its inhabitants. By addressing the environmental and social concerns associated with material extraction, we can create a more holistic and comprehensive approach to the clean energy transition that benefits all stakeholders.
Some measures that can be taken include:
The adoption of environmentally friendly and energy-efficient mining practices, such as using renewable energy sources for operations, reducing water usage, and minimising land degradation, is vital for a sustainable transition.
Strict environmental, labour, and social standards must be implemented and enforced to prevent negative impacts on local communities and ecosystems, while ensuring the protection of human rights.
Recycling and reusing materials from end-of-life products, such as batteries and electronic waste, is essential. Analysts predict that recycling could meet 9% of global lithium demand by 2025, and novel techniques such as "urban" biomining to extract REEs from electronic waste using microorganisms are already being developed.
Source: ChemistryWorld
By diversifying the sources of materials through investing in mining projects in various countries and regions, we can reduce dependency on a single supplier or region, and mitigate geopolitical risks.
There must be investment in the research and development of alternative materials and technologies that can replace or reduce the reliance on critical materials. Some companies are already exploring ways to reduce the cobalt content of batteries by increasing nickel content, while others are investigating the use of sodium, magnesium, graphene, hydrogen fuel cells, and other alternatives in place of lithium.
Transparency and traceability in the supply chain of critical materials must be encouraged to ensure ethical sourcing and responsible practices. This can be achieved through the implementation of certification schemes and industry-wide standards.
Collaboration among governments, businesses, researchers, and civil society must occur in order to address the challenges of sustainable material sourcing, share best practices, and drive innovation.
The public should be made aware of the environmental and social impacts of material extraction, and encouraged to demand products made using sustainable and responsible practices.
As the global community faces the urgent challenge of climate change, securing the necessary raw materials for a clean energy transition is of paramount importance. There is hope that sustainable changes can be made in the mining, refinement, and extraction processes to ensure a truly responsible and environmentally friendly approach to securing these critical materials. By implementing innovative solutions, it is possible to create a clean energy future that benefits both the planet and its people.
Key sources:
